By Ed Hackett [email protected]
Choosing the best motor oil is a topic that comes up frequently in discussions between motoheads, whether they are talking about motorcycle s or cars. The following article is intended to help you make a choice based on more than the advertising hype.Edits:
* v1.0 First there was 1.0. Before that there was darkness.
* v1.1 Change in description of viscosity.
* v1.2 Updated info on AMSOIL (courtesy of Morgan McArthur [email protected])
Oil companies provide data on their oils most often referred to as “typical inspection data”. This is an average of the actual physical and a few common chemical properties of their oils. This information is available to the public through their distributors or by writing or calling the company directly. I have compiled a list of the most popular, premium oils so that a ready comparison can be made. If your favorite oil is not on the list get the data from the distributor and use what I have as a data base.
This article is going to look at six of the most important properties of a motor oil readily available to the public: viscosity, viscosity index (VI), flash point, pour point, % sulfated ash, and % zinc.
Viscosity is a measure of the “flowability” of an oil. More specifically, it is the property of an oil to develop and maintain a certain amount of shearing stress dependent on flow, and then to offer continued resistance to flow. Thicker oils generally have a higher viscosity, and thinner oils a lower viscosity. This is the most important property for an engine. An oil with too low a viscosity can shear and lose film strength at high temperatures. An oil with too high a viscosity may not pump to the proper parts at low temperatures and the film may tear at high rpm.
The weights given on oils are arbitrary numbers assigned by the S.A.E. (Society of Automotive Engineers). These numbers correspond to “real” viscosity, as measured by several accepted techniques. These measurements are taken at specific temperatures. Oils that fall into a certain range are designated 5, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 by the S.A.E. The W means the oil meets specifications for viscosity at 0 F and is therefore suitable for Winter use.
Multi viscosity oils work like this: Polymers are added to a light base (5W, 10W, 20W), which prevent the oil from thinning as much as it warms up. At cold temperatures the polymers are coiled up and allow the oil to flow as their low numbers indicate. As the oil warms up the polymers begin to unwind into long chains that prevent the oil from thinning as much as it normally would. The result is that at 100 degrees C the oil has thinned only as much as the higher viscosity number indicates. Another way of looking at multi-vis oils is to think of a 20W-50 as a 20 weight oil that will not thin more than a 50 weight would when hot.
Multi viscosity oils are one of the great improvements in oils, but they should be chosen wisely. Always use a multi grade with the narrowest span of viscosity that is appropriate for the temperatures you are going to encounter. In the winter base your decision on the lowest temperature you will encounter, in the summer, the highest temperature you expect. The polymers can shear and burn forming deposits that can cause ring sticking and other problems. 10W-40 and 5W-30 require a lot of polymers (synthetics excluded) to achieve that range. This has caused problems in diesel engines, but fewer polymers are better for all engines. The wide viscosity range oils, in general, are more prone to viscosity and thermal breakdown due to the high polymer content. It is the oil that lubricates, not the additives. Oils that can do their job with the fewest additives are the best.
Very few manufactures recommend 10W-40 any more, and some threaten to void warranties if it is used. It was not included in this article for that reason. 20W-50 is the same 30 point spread, but because it starts with a heavier base it requires less viscosity index improvers (polymers) to do the job. AMSOIL can formulate their 10W-30 and 15W-40 with no viscosity index improvers but uses some in the 10W-40 and 5W-30. Mobil 1 uses no viscosity improvers in their 5W-30, and I assume the new 10W-30. Follow your manufacturer’s recommendations as to which weights are appropriate for your vehicle.
Viscosity Index is an empirical number indicating the rate o f change in viscosity of an oil within a given temperature range. Higher numbers indicate a low change, lower numbers indicate a relatively large change. The higher the number the better. This is one major property of an oil that keeps your bearings happy. These numbers can only be compared within a viscosity range. It is not an indication of how well the oil resists thermal breakdown.
Flash point is the temperature at which an oil gives off vapors that can be ignited with a flame held over the oil. The lower the flash point the greater tendency for the oil to suffer vaporization loss at high temperatures and to burn off on hot cylinder walls and pistons. The flash point can be an indicator of the quality of the base stock used. The higher the flash point the better. 400 F is the minimum to prevent possible high consumption. Flash point is in degrees F.
Pour point is 5 degrees F above the point at which a chilled oil shows no movement at the surface for 5 seconds when inclined. This measurement is especially important for oils used in the winter. A borderline pumping temperature is given by some manufacturers. This is the temperature at which the oil will pump and maintain adequate oil pressure. This was not given by a lot of the manufacturers, but seems to be about 20 degrees F above the pour point. The lower the pour point the better. Pour point is in degrees F.
% sulfated ash is how much solid material is left when the oil burns. A high ash content will tend to form more sludge and deposits in the engine. Low ash content also seems to promote long valve life. Look for oils with a low ash content.
% zinc is the amount of zinc used as an extreme pressure, anti-wear additive. The zinc is only used when there is actual metal to metal contact in the engine. Hopefully the oil will do its job and this will rarely occur, but if it does, the zinc compounds react with the metal to prevent scuffing and wear. A level of .11% is enough to protect an automobile engine for the extended oil drain interval, under normal use. Those of you with high revving, air cooled motorcycles or turbo charged cars or bikes might want to look at the oils with the higher zinc content. More doesn’t give you better protection, it gives you longer protection if the rate of metal to metal contact is abnormally high. High zinc content can lead to deposit formation and plug fouling.
The Data: Listed alphabetically — indicates the data was not available
| Brand | VI | Flash | Pour | % Ash | % Zinc | Brand | VI | Flash | Pour | % Ash | % Zinc |
| 20W-50 | 20W-40 | ||||||||||
| AMSOIL (old) | 136 | 482 | -38 | <.5 | — | AMSOIL | 124 | 500 | -49 | — | — |
| AMSOIL (new) | 157 | 507 | -44 | — | — | Castrol Multi-Grade | 110 | 440 | -15 | .85 | .12 |
| Castrol GTX | 122 | 440 | -15 | .85 | .12 | Quaker State | 121 | 415 | -15 | .9 | — |
| Exxon High Performance | 119 | 419 | -13 | .70 | .11 | 15W-50 | |||||
| Havoline Formula 3 | 125 | 465 | -30 | 1.0 | — | Chevron | 204 | 415 | -18 | .96 | .11 |
| Kendall GT-1 | 129 | 390 | -25 | 1.0 | .16 | Mobil 1 | 170 | 470 | -55 | — | — |
| Pennzoil GT Perf. | 120 | 460 | -10 | .9 | — | Mystic JT8 | 144 | 420 | -20 | 1.7 | .15 |
| Quaker State Dlx. | 155 | 430 | -25 | .9 | — | Red Line | 152 | 503 | -49 | — | — |
| Red Line | 150 | 503 | -49 | — | — | 5W-50 | |||||
| Shell Truck Guard | 130 | 450 | -15 | 1.0 | .15 | Castrol Syntec | 180 | 437 | -45 | 1.2 | .10 |
| Spectro Golden 4 | 174 | 440 | -35 | — | .15 | Quaker State Synquest | 173 | 457 | -76 | — | — |
| Spectro Golden M.G. | 174 | 440 | -35 | — | .13 | Pennzoil Performax | 176 | — | |||
| — | — | ||||||||||
| Unocal | 121 | 432 | -11 | .74 | .12 | 5W-40 | |||||
| Valvoline All Climate | 125 | 430 | -10 | 1.0 | .11 | Havoline | 170 | 450 | -40 | 1.4 | — |
| Valvoline Turbo | 140 | 440 | -10 | .99 | .13 | 10W-30 | |||||
| Valvoline Race | 140 | 425 | -10 | 1.2 | .20 | AMSOIL (old) | 142 | 480 | -70 | <.5 | — |
| Valvoline Synthetic | 146 | 465 | -40 | <1.5 | .12 | AMSOIL (new) | 162 | 520 | -76 | — | — |
| 15W-40 | Castrol GTX | 140 | 415 | -33 | .85 | .12 | |||||
| AMSOIL (old) | 135 | 460 | -38 | <.5 | — | Chevron Supreme | 150 | 401 | -26 | .96 | .11 |
| AMSOIL (new) | 164 | 462 | -49 | — | — | Exxon Superflo Hi Perf | 135 | 392 | -22 | .70 | .11 |
| Castrol | 134 | 415 | -15 | 1.3 | .14 | Exxon Superflo Supreme | 133 | 400 | -31 | .85 | .13 |
| Chevron Delo 400 | 136 | 421 | -27 | 1.0 | — | Havoline Formula 3 | 139 | 430 | -30 | 1.0 | — |
| Exxon XD3 | — | 417 | -11 | .9 | .14 | Kendall GT-1 | 139 | 390 | -25 | 1.0 | .16 |
| Exxon XD3 Extra | 135 | 399 | -11 | .95 | .13 | Mobil 1 | 160 | 450 | -65 | — | — |
| Kendall GT-1 | 135 | 410 | -25 | 1.0 | .16 | Pennzoil PLZ Turbo | 140 | 410 | -27 | 1.0 | — |
| Mystic JT8 | 142 | 440 | -20 | 1.7 | .15 | Quaker State | 156 | 410 | -30 | .9 | — |
| Red Line | 149 | 495 | -40 | — | — | Red Line | 139 | 475 | -40 | — | — |
| Shell Rotella w/XLA | 146 | 410 | -25 | 1.0 | .13 | Shell Fire and Ice | 155 | 410 | -35 | .9 | .12 |
| Valvoline All Fleet | 140 | — | -10 | 1.0 | .15 | Shell Super 2000 | 155 | 410 | -35 | 1.0 | .13 |
| Valvoline Turbo | 140 | 420 | -10 | .99 | .13 | Shell Truck Guard | 155 | 405 | -35 | 1.0 | .15 |
| 5W-30 | Spectro Golden M.G. | 175 | 405 | -40 | — | — | |||||
| AMSOIL (old) | 168 | 480 | -76 | <.5 | — | Unocal Super | 153 | 428 | -33 | .92 | .12 |
| AMSOIL (new) | 186 | 464 | -76 | — | — | Valvoline All Climate | 130 | 410 | -26 | 1.0 | .11 |
| Castrol GTX | 156 | 400 | -35 | .80 | .12 | Valvoline Turbo | 135 | 410 | -26 | .99 | .13 |
| Chevron Supreme | 202? | 354 | -46 | .96 | .11 | Valvoline Race< /TD> | 130 | 410 | -26 | 1.2 | .20 |
| Chevron Supreme Synt. | 165 | 446 | -72 | 1.1 | .12 | Valvoline Synthetic | 140 | 450 | -40 | <1.5 | .12 |
| Exxon Superflow HP | 148 | 392 | -22 | .70 | .11 | ||||||
| Havoline Formula 3 | 158 | 420 | -40 | 1.0 | — | ||||||
| Mystic JT8 | 161 | 390 | -25 | .95 | .1 | ||||||
| Quaker State | 165 | 405 | -35 | .9 | — | ||||||
| Red Line | 151 | 455 | -49 | — | — | ||||||
| Shell Fire and Ice | 167 | 405 | -35 | .9 | .12 | ||||||
| Unocal | 151 | 414 | -33 | .81 | .12 | ||||||
| Valvoline All Climate | 135 | 405 | -40 | 1.0 | .11 | ||||||
| Valvol ine Turbo | 158 | 405 | -40 | .99 | .13 | ||||||
| Valvoline Synthetic | 160 | 435 | -40 | <1.5 | .12 |
All of the oils above meet current SG/CD ratings and all vehicle manufacture’s warranty requirements in the proper viscosity. All are “good enough”, but those with the better numbers are icing on the cake.
The synthetics offer the only truly significant differences, due to their superior high temperature oxidation resistance, high film strength, very low tendency to form deposits, stable viscosity base, and low temperature flow characteristics. Synthetics are superior lubricants compared to traditional petroleum oils. You will have to decide if their high cost is justified in your application.
The extended oil drain intervals given by the vehicle manufacturers (typically 7500 miles) and synthetic oil companies (up to 25,000 miles) are for what is called normal service. Normal service is defined as the engine at normal operating temperature, at highway speeds, and in a dust free environment. Stop and go, city driving, trips of less than 10 miles, or extreme heat or cold puts the oil change interval into the severe service category, which is 3000 miles for most vehicles. Synthetics can be run two to three times the mileage of petroleum oils with no problems. They do not react to combustion and combustion by-products to the extent that the dead dinosaur juice does. The longer drain intervals possible help take the bite out of the higher cost of the synthetics. If your car or bike is still under warranty you will have to stick to the recommended drain intervals. These are set for petroleum oils and the manufacturers make no official allowance for the use of synthetics.
Oil additives should not be used. The oil companies have gone to great lengths to develop an additive package that meets the vehicle’s requirements. Some of these additives are synergistic, that is the effect of two additives together is greater than the effect of each acting separately. If you add anything to the oil you may upset this balance and prevent the oil from performing to specification.
The numbers above are not, by any means, all there is to determining what makes a top quality oil. The exact base stock used, the type, quality, and quantity of additives used are very important. The given data combined with the manufacturer’s claims, your personal experience, and the reputation of the oil among others who use it should help you make an informed choice.
